Vanessa Minnillo vs. Susie Castillo – An MTV Bastardly Matchup

Oh yes….you got 2 of the sexiest VJays on MTV… and neither of them are white! GO MINORITIES!!!

Secret wish: to re-enact that scene in Old School of Blue, the 2 topless chicks, and the swimming pool filled w/ KY gelly with these 2 lovelies…of course w/o the dropping dead part.

View All Photos ›

18 comments
Aisha P
Aisha P

They are both so naturally gorgeous, but i think Vanessa has a nicer body and a slightly prettier face. Susie is super cute though. I love her hair.

Tyra
Tyra

Vanessa's face is soooo bloated and she has a ton of pock marks. Susie is way cuter.

didier
didier

non slanted eyed mongoloid??

hermanita
hermanita

None of those pics are really good ones of Susie...I think she might not be that photogenic. But she is soooo hot and so is Vanessa. I can not choose, for ones. Both are equally hot.

Eric
Eric

You all should check out Susie's website (I'm a fan obviously) there are some bangin' pics of her. She's beautiful and def gets my vote hands down!!!

Check out the site...

www.susiecastillo.net

jake
jake

This is not a great pic of Susie. She is soooo hot just as much as Vanessa. Love TRL now with these two hotties!!!

Greg
Greg

VANESSA!! without a doubt!!.. shes so hot!! and she sat on my LAP during LIVE TRL!!... its on my webpage!! I LOVE HER!!!

avi
avi

vanessa is a true bitch...i know from past run-ins when she lived in the o.c....susie is soooooooooooo sweet...vanessa is such a sell-out, she had NOTHING...would make out with all my friends as well as myself just to hang out in the v.i.p. section with us...it makes me sick that she has america fooled as the cute girl next door...also, what's the story with her fake tan? she was white when i knew her...(2 years ago), now it looks like she's been on the sands in bali.

gwen
gwen

vanessa has a much more interesting look, i can never get bored of her sexy features she looks good no matter what. susie on the other hand is not bad looking, but she just looks like a typical girl...

Sasha
Sasha

I agree, Susie is not a bad looking girl but Vanessa is gorgeous. And they both have such beautiful curly hair!

ikki
ikki

vanessa is a goddess

Arika
Arika

vanessa is gorgeous. susie is alright, but vanessa is definatly hotter.

Nancy
Nancy

Vanessa is beautiful.Susie is well...she's cute from the nose up.Something about her mouth and chin bother me.

Rome Dawg
Rome Dawg

another good matchup Jacks...i've gotta go with Vanessa...the right stuff!!!!!!

kari
kari

va...nes...sa wow, susie has such an annoying face!

Enrique
Enrique

Theyre both fucking gorgoues. *drools*