Antonella Barba vs. Alaina Alexander – The Bastardly American Idol Hot Eliminated Chicks Matchup

In my Bastardly opinion, two of my favorites that got eliminated from the American Idol round of 24. Of course The Bastardly has love for Antonella Barba in all her pee-pee glory and the buzz has long but died. However, at the same time let’s give Alaina Alexander some due also. A nice little package she’s got going on, very desirable to me. You know the drill, I tried to make the comparison pictures as even as possible with what I had to work with. Granted, I had 6 pictures of Alaina and like 70 of Antonella.

View All Photos ›

11 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Fraz
Fraz

Ugh. Alaina by a mile. Barba's nothing but a skank. A nasty one at that. Glad she got kicked off so she can waste away in obscurity.

pinoyIdol
pinoyIdol

Who's a better slut? that's Antonella....

Who's the one u can bring home and meet ur parents? that's Alaina....

Antonella is only good for sex.

Captain Fatnutz
Captain Fatnutz

ya gotta go with the sleazier one. who would rather take a load in the face? who could handle a donkey punch and ask for another?

the answer is clear. Antonella FTW

Sullen Girl
Sullen Girl

Alaina looks like Alanis Morrisette. Which is gross.

christine
christine

Barba has a smokin' body, but she needs to keep her mouth shut with that fucking gummy smile...

Turd Ferguson
Turd Ferguson

I wouldn't hit a dog in the ass with either one of these no talent bitches!!

Piss off skanks!!!

Eduardo "the freek"
Eduardo "the freek"

Alaina is hot. I've said it from the beginning. Her face is just so cute.

Maripito
Maripito

I can't wait to see Antonella Barba doing some porn in the pile driver position. Its only a matter of time for that no talent fluzie.

Dave
Dave

i think i like Alaina's face better. Antonella's got a killer rack though

Rasheed
Rasheed

Is you kidding me? Barba wins without even trying! I love this ho!

LZ
LZ

Barba FTW, pretty face and nice tits