Miral: Film Review

Miral, based on Rula Jabreal’s autobiographical novel of the same name, details the struggle, the suffering and the hope of the Palestinian people. Some who see the film will see little but anti-Israeli propaganda, a curious accusation when the film is directed Julian Schnabel. Or perhaps the accusation is not so curious precisely because the film is directed by Julian Schnabel. It is worth mentioning that Jabreal also happens to be Schnabel’s girlfriend in real life.

The protagonist Miral begins the film by saying that her story begins much earlier with the birth of the Israeli state and the personal crusade endured by Hind Husseini (a superb Hiam Abbas) who began Dar El Tifl, a school for abandoned Palestinian girls whose only recourse is to wither away without the aid of heroines like Hind. There is Miral’s mother Nadia, an abused young woman who flees the horrors of being sodomized daily and becomes a belly dancer who lands in prison for slapping an Israeli woman. There she meets Fatima, a former nurse sentenced to three life sentences for attempting to blow up a movie theater as an act of rebellion against the Israeli occupation. Finally, Miral Shahin is born, but her mother cannot bear the pain of living and she drowns herself, leaving Miral to her doting father who raises her with the help of Hind and Dar El Tifl. Miral, we soon discover, is not like the other girls. And then, at the same time, she is too much like the other girls.

The tagline of the movie has doe-eyed Freida Pinto (Slumdog Millionaire’s Latika) dressed up in a school girl’s uniform sitting on a bench and asking, pointedly, Is This the Face of a Terrorist? The answer, we all know, is an impossible one to conjure, no matter what your position on the existence of a Palestinian state may be. Like so many other recent films about those who commit acts of violence in the name of a political cause or religion (like Paradise Now, Santosh Sivan’s The Terrorist, and Mani Ratnam’s 1998 surreal masterpiece Dil Se), the filmmakers know that such stories make us uncomfortable because they force us to think (or at least attempt to think) from the perspective of another human being whose humanity has been denied by the global collective (remember that “Philistine” is still synonymous with “barbarian” and “offensive”). Once we do that, we begin to wonder what drives people to blow themselves up for their forsaken communities or outside abortion clinics. We may wonder, does this mean George Washington was a “terrorist”? Can anyone who ever lifted a weapon in the face of oppression be defined as a terrorist?

Schnabel isn’t interested in answering the questions his movie poses. Rather, it just wants to ask the questions, throw them out into the world, and maybe perhaps have some semblance of peaceful introspection returned in hand. Is Miral a terrorist? Is she a patriot? Is she both? Is she something else altogether? Or, perhaps, she is a casualty, like millions of others born in strife, routinely degraded and dehumanized, whose only wish is to be validated, to be seen as whole, to be looked upon in the fullness of their humanity, and to be included with the rest of the human race.

Some reviewers have remarked that the strangest moment in the film comes when Miral and her revolutionary lover Hani are reunited and – in the midst of an intense makeout session – begin to espouse hope for the future of their nations and the possibility of co-existence with Israel. Yes, it is a bit jarring, but when one steps back and looks at the totality of their reality, it actually makes sense: the establishment of a Palestinian state is the overriding sentiment of their lives – greater even than that of all-important Love – and around this central idea do all the other moments and movements in Life occur. As such, the moment of reunion between Miral and Hani makes perfect sense – it isn’t romantic and it isn’t a magical movie kiss a la Lady & the Tramp, but in the context of Miral’s struggle, it is entirely plausible.

In the end, the film is really about Love: Love for one’s country, for a cause greater than oneself, for one’s family and cherished ones, and for all of humanity. Such all-encompassing and idealized humanism may sound trite and even overly sentimental, but Schnabel is able to lift much beauty out of the barrenness of the Israeli-Palestinian landscape and its undying conundrum, both literally and figuratively. As Palestinian Miral asks Lisa, her cousin’s Israeli girlfriend, “How can you love an Arab man?” Lisa’s plaintive reply? “How can I not?”

Indeed.


32 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
joey
joey

This film was destined to bomb at the box office because it's sympathetic to the Palestinians' plight. As a consequence, it wasn't marketed very well so few people got a chance to see it. Its detractors are certainly very satisfied with that outcome.

junglegirl
junglegirl

you're a perv and an uneducated pos.

d55
d55

You invade their lands, and when they naturally fight back, they are terrorists? Get the fuck out of here. How would you feel and do if someone came and invaded your land and killed your people? I'll bet you'd fight back by any means, and it would be fair to call you a terrorist? You should spend less time on here and more time trying to find some real truth. A man your age should know better than into buying BS your media feeds you.

dims
dims

Not watching this dump of a movie. Maybe, i'll be a little open minded.

Boz
Boz

true that.

Glimmer
Glimmer

abba's reviews always make the most popular stories thing/list at the top of the page. :)

lazydayz
lazydayz

Seriously, Abba should be writing for a newspaper or magazine or something. No offense, Moe.

McPerv
McPerv

LOL, I did have to google her just to be sure. :-)

McLady
McLady

Shalom. Dont try to be all clever. You know us brown people all look the same to you honkies.

Boz
Boz

Jai Ho!

Boz
Boz

what McPerv said.

Invigorator
Invigorator

Statistically speaking...very unlikely because

1. She is a woman

2. Not Muslim

3. Indian heritage

dagon
dagon

Doesn't matter the question that they wanted to pose is do we think a terrorist can looks this way to which I will reply sure terrorist can be white also or Asian doesn't matter as long as you believe that killing other humans for a imaginary thing in the sky, is good, you are a terrorist

McPerv
McPerv

No, that isn't the face of a terrorist. Because she's Indian, not Arab. Duh.

dagon
dagon

Answer: Yes, yes it is.

skilligan
skilligan

she is pretty enough to make me go see it

Glimmer
Glimmer

abba,the wordsmith of our dreams has returned !!!! :)