Won’t Back Down: Film Review
Visit the film’s official website!
Won’t Back Down is an unfortunate movie: it’s the kind of movie with a good heart and a good message with equally good intentions . . . but which is horribly, terribly handled and ends up being little more than the average movie of the week circa 1992. We have the main character of Jamie Fitzpatrick (Maggie Gyllenhaal) who is a single mom working two jobs too busy to give much attention to her dyslexic grade-school aged daughter. Eventually, things become so intolerable for her child in school that she is compelled to join forces with a teacher named Nona (Viola Davis) to break the school from the clutches of an uncaring and indifferent bureaucracy that puts profits and teacher union rights ahead of children and their education. How noble.
It is noble. Really. But the movie is played with such “I-Believe-The-Chidlren-Are-Our-Future” cheesy earnestness that you begin to roll your eyes every time Ms. Gyllenhaal happens upon the scene to give yet another soap box speech about mothers and daughters or tell off another smarmy teacher who tries to dismiss her child as “challenged”. Gyllenhaal gives such an over-the-top and loud performance you can’t help but wonder what her aim was: perhaps she thought that if she yelled at the camera enough times she might get an Oscar nod? Meryl Streep was certainly loud and chewed up the scenery in Doubt. The difference is that character was supposed to be a virago. This one is caring mother whose decibels outweigh any real life attempt at negotiating the well-being of a child. Sorry, Maggie, this won’t be your Erin Brockovich.
Viola Davis is mercifully more restrained and gives a solid, dependable performance. The rest of the cast (which includes Holly Hunter and Rosie Perez) does its best with the material their given, though it doesn’t add up to as much as they would perhaps hope. If only director Daniel Barnz spent more time fleshing out all the characters instead of giving Maggie Gyllenhaal the lion’s share of scream time to roar.